Storyworld · Argumentation game

Hero or Criminal?

A short original-game station about conflicting narratives, evidence and fair disagreement.

Original narrative game · 5-minute challenge

Hero or Criminal?

An imaginary coastal city is split over Captain Nera. A circulating clip shows her removing the city's ceremonial banner from a government hall. Is she a thief, a protester, or something else? Your task is not to guess the author's preferred answer—it is to reason carefully.

Source A

The clip

A 12-second fragment, released without a date or preceding footage, shows Captain Nera leaving with the banner.

Source B

The witness

A guard says a flood had damaged the building, but he was not present when the banner was removed.

Source C

The official

A city spokesperson accuses Nera of theft but refuses to release the full security recording.

Question 1 · Evidence

Question 2 · Credibility

Question 3 · Argument

This is an entry station into the École's broader argumentation courses. The course can later use licensed media case studies, but this demonstration deliberately uses original characters.

Continue to the Argument Arena →